Remodeling News: Improve or Move?

11/19/2026
Posted in News
11/19/2026 Dave Gooden

A November remodeling report offers a useful reminder for Twin Cities homeowners: spending more on a house is not the same as making a better housing decision. Before committing to a major project, decide whether you are improving the home for your own use, preparing to sell or trying to make staying more attractive than moving. Those are different goals, and they can lead to very different scopes of work.

In its November 9, 2026 release, the National Association of Home Builders reported that its modeled second-quarter remodeling spending showed an average growth rate of zero across the states. Spending increased in 24 states and declined in 26. The organization also pointed to construction costs as a constraint and aging homes as a source of longer-term demand. This was a national, backward-looking spending analysis, not a prediction of what a particular Minnesota renovation will cost or add to resale value.

The important distinction: spending, usefulness and resale

Three questions deserve separate answers. What will the work cost? How much will it improve your daily life? How might a future buyer respond? A project can be worthwhile for the second reason without recovering its entire cost through a sale. That does not make it a mistake, provided the decision is made with that distinction in mind.

For example, a highly customized workspace may be valuable to someone who uses it every day. A future buyer may prefer a simpler room with a different purpose. The practical response is not to avoid personalization altogether. It is to understand which choices serve your own use and avoid presenting the money spent as a guaranteed addition to the home’s price.

If you expect to sell soon, diagnose before renovating

A homeowner preparing to sell can easily build a long project list by walking through the house with a critical eye. The more useful exercise is to identify the problems buyers are likely to notice and determine which ones deserve action. Maintenance, presentation and a large renovation should not be treated as one interchangeable category.

Begin with condition and function. Ask which issues require qualified assessment, which can be addressed with limited work and which should be disclosed and reflected in the overall offering. Then look at the competitive set. If buyers have attractive alternatives, the right response may involve price and presentation rather than attempting to match every feature in a newly renovated home.

Before approving a significant project, discuss its likely effect on the selling timeline and budget. An improvement that delays your move for months may not be the best answer even if it is appealing. Request written estimates, understand exclusions and leave room for uncertainty. Do not rely on a general market headline to justify a very specific expenditure.

If you plan to stay, define the problem the project solves

Staying can be a thoughtful choice when the location works and a practical change could improve the home. But a project should solve an identifiable problem. Is circulation awkward? Is essential storage missing? Does the layout make routine tasks harder than they need to be? A clear brief is more useful than a collection of attractive photographs with no priorities.

Consider whether a smaller intervention could deliver most of the benefit. Better lighting, more usable storage or a targeted layout adjustment may deserve comparison with a complete overhaul. Have qualified professionals assess feasibility, especially when structural, electrical, plumbing or accessibility questions are involved. The point is not automatically to choose the cheapest solution, but to understand what each level of spending accomplishes.

Compare renovating with a real moving alternative

The stay-or-move calculation should compare actual options. Review available homes, estimated selling costs, purchase expenses and the disruption associated with either path. A hypothetical ideal home is not a fair comparison with a detailed renovation bid, and a rough renovation guess is not a fair comparison with a specific listing.

Exploring Eden Prairie luxury homes can help clarify what a move would change and what compromises might remain. A different property may solve several problems at once, or it may introduce new maintenance and location tradeoffs. The comparison becomes more useful when you include daily routines alongside the financial figures.

A flat industry report does not guarantee a bargain

National spending can be flat while a particular contractor remains busy or a selected material remains expensive. Obtain project-specific information instead of assuming that a slower housing market gives every homeowner the same negotiating position. Compare bids on the same scope, specifications and responsibilities.

Ask how changes will be documented and how payment is tied to the agreement. Verify relevant credentials and insurance with appropriate sources. If the contract is substantial or unclear, seek qualified legal advice. A lower estimate is not automatically a better value if it leaves important work undefined.

Keep a record of what you improve

Save invoices, permits where applicable, product information and warranty documents in an organized file. Record what was actually completed rather than relying on memory several years later. When it is time to sell, accurate records can help explain the home’s history without overstating what the improvements mean for value.

The positive takeaway from the remodeling news is that homeowners have reason to be selective, not discouraged. A carefully scoped project can make a home more useful, while a thoughtful decision not to renovate can preserve money and flexibility. The best choice is the one that serves your plans and rests on credible numbers, rather than the assumption that more spending must produce a better outcome.

David Gooden is a luxury real estate agent serving Twin Cities buyers and sellers, especially in the western and southwestern suburbs. Construction, financing and tax questions should be reviewed with the appropriate qualified professionals.

Call David at (612) 367-6025 | Text David | Email David

Close